The San Diego City and County Administration Building, where the Board of Supervisors meets. Photo: Tony Webster, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
San Diego County’s free lawyers-for-immigrants program has the money to grow but not enough attorneys willing to take the cases. On Tuesday, the Board of Supervisors told county staff to fix that.
The board voted 3-1 to strengthen the Immigrant Legal Defense Program, which pays private attorneys to represent people facing deportation who cannot afford a lawyer. Supervisors Paloma Aguirre, Terra Lawson-Remer and Monica Montgomery Steppe voted yes, Jim Desmond voted no and Joel Anderson was absent, according to the county’s meeting record for item 25 on the Nov. 17 agenda.
The action does not add money right away. The board letter from Lawson-Remer and Aguirre says the work will be handled with existing Public Defender staff and existing general fund revenue, with no change in net general fund costs. What it does is order a recruiting and quality plan for the panel of attorneys who take the cases, and a public accounting of how long people wait for one.
Longer detentions, more calls
The numbers in the board letter show why the program’s supporters say it is stretched. Citing the program’s latest annual report, the letter says the median time clients spent in immigration detention nearly doubled in one year, from 86 days to 167, and calls from new clients seeking help rose 130%.
Since it began taking cases in 2022, the program has worked on more than 3,500 cases, the letter says, and in 52% of cases with a substantive outcome, the client was allowed to extend their stay in the United States. Others were ordered deported. During the last fiscal year, 66 attorneys took cases through the program, up from 55 the year before, and the letter describes 66 as the panel’s current maximum capacity.
Costs are also climbing. Projected program spending rises from $5 million in fiscal 2025-26 to $12.6 million in 2026-27 and $17.3 million in 2027-28, according to the letter, which argues that “additional funding alone cannot guarantee that eligible clients will receive timely representation” without more attorneys.
What the county will build
The board directed the chief administrative officer to work with the Public Defender’s Office and the Office of Assigned Counsel on a policies and procedures manual for panel attorneys. Among the pieces:
- A written recruitment and retention plan with measurable goals, including recurring outreach at local law schools, the San Diego County Bar Association, immigration-law groups and affinity bar associations.
- Expanded mentorship that pairs newer attorneys with experienced immigration practitioners, building on the American Bar Association’s Immigrant Justice Program, with a focus on detained cases, removal defense and bond hearings.
- Minimum practice standards, required training and a graduated process for coaching or removing attorneys who fall short.
- A merit-blind assignment system, so a client’s chance of getting a lawyer does not depend on a prediction of whether they will win, plus a transparent waitlist that tracks referral dates, custody status and how long people wait for counsel when demand outruns capacity.
Staff are due back within 120 days with an implementation plan that includes expected costs, funding sources and baseline data. After that, the county is supposed to report regularly on the number of active attorneys, caseloads, waitlists and outcomes. Any new costs would come back to the board for a separate vote.
The vote adds to a string of local decisions on how San Diego agencies handle federal immigration enforcement, including the San Diego Police Department’s pledge this month to report more often when officers encounter immigration agents. More coverage is on our Border & Binational page, along with our guide to crossing at San Ysidro and Otay Mesa.


